The Revolution Must Be Inclusive

I’m not a member of Extinction Rebellion and it’s a movement I have mixed feelings about. There are a lot of people I like and admire who are getting involved. There are a fair few people co-opting it for self promotion purposes, or to further other personal projects. That it is getting attention for climate crisis is important. That its means do not align reliably with its intended ends is a problem for me.

I am absolutely in favour of gathering in Trafalgar Square to speak truth to power. Protesting in the right place, in the faces of those in power whose minds need changing, is a good idea. Not all of it goes this way, which I think is counter-productive. I’ve seen a lot of it locally and there have been too many actions that alienate people rather than engaging them.

To radically change our cultures, our behaviour, our laws and politics, we needs as many people persuaded as possible. That makes the question of who to inconvenience, and how, an important one. An inclusive movement draws people in and persuades them. There is going to be discomfort for people whose lifestyles are not sustainable, and there will be pushback, but if people feel too uncomfortable, they’re more likely to dig in and resist change, which does not help.

I worry about the way in which many Green activities look like middle class hobbies. It suits certain areas of the media to push that message, because persuading most people that it’s snobbery and hypocrisy and not for them is an effective way of maintaining the status quo. Activists need to think carefully about this because we need more people engaging, not being put off. It is important not to price people out of participation. Protesting in ways that hurt people who are already struggling isn’t an appealing look.

I’ve been in a lot of spaces where I was the youngest person in the room, as a middle aged person, conscious that an even younger person might have had a much harder time of feeling comfortable there. The assumption that you are retired and can afford the time is a big assumption, and a common one. I’ve been in so many spaces where the assumption of middle class affluence was a real problem for me, and I’ve heard people say some pretty awful things about ‘the poor’ in those contexts.

It isn’t easy for people who feel themselves to be normal, to see who is missing from the room. All-male spaces don’t notice the lack of women as an issue. All-middle-class spaces don’t notice the lack of working class people. All-white spaces don’t notice the lack of ethnic diversity. Able bodied groups do not notice the lack of disabled people. And so on. Invariably, it becomes the job of the first person in the room not to fit to try and make that space. Which is exhausting and difficult and thankless. We should not be making disadvantaged people fight to get into the room and fight for a space at the table. We should be smoothing the way whenever we can.

If you think ‘those people’ aren’t in your movement because ‘they’ don’t really care about that sort of thing, please rethink this. If you’re treating a demographic as all being the same, you are going to be making terrible mistakes. If you’re participating, and seeing someone else’s lack of participation as them not being the sort of person who would, you won’t change anything. When you ask what you can do to be more inclusive and to enable more people to get involved and see green movements as for them, in their interests, and spaces where they would be welcome, you can make changes.

A non-inclusive revolution won’t work. A revolution for the middle classes won’t tackle many of the ways in which poverty and environmental problems go hand in hand. A revolution that isn’t for everyone, isn’t going to work. It will take maximum engagement to really change things. It should fall to those who are most able to help people get involved. If something is easy for you that doesn’t mean it’s easy for everyone.

About Nimue Brown

Druid, author, dreamer, folk enthusiast, parent, polyamourous animist, ant-fash, anti-capitalist, bisexual steampunk. Drinker of coffee, maker of puddings. Exploring life as a Pagan, seeking good and meaningful ways to be, struggling with mental health issues and worried about many things. View all posts by Nimue Brown

11 responses to “The Revolution Must Be Inclusive

  • Barney Rubble

    Your script on the tree reads well. Thanks. Good to hear you.

  • Helen Bell

    I could not agree with you more – really well put. It’s hard to know what to do about this issue.

  • Leonard

    Nice post. Your thoughts are valued.

  • smithandskarry1

    Spot on as usual. Exactly what we were saying here the other day!

  • eberis

    I might be bothering .. the protest of London is as far as I know dwindling last week . the meetings are held in private and the laggers seem to be running a decoy of going the other way to prevent uniform police from finding the meeting . the lagger I meant is someone who in hearsay was accosted by police who couldn’t help it … the enforcement program of their radio call in was trying to enforce the law . the police were kind and used a technique of community rule which is to allow one terror suspect to leave as monitored and scanned and then let free . the mythpunk in question went home and tried signing on what happened on the internet before IPv solves home automation .. which the police monitored to see if there is a connection and then left it alone . my advent to this is the Chief of Police networking I use to get mythpunk online the so called reduction of philosophy of Pantheon Series in regard to the myriad of deities who inhabit the Heavens of the 10 Systems Star N Planet and beyond into our cosmis system ; have the sign on of a myth called angelib . the mythpunk of protest of London who was accosted by police will want with a Pantheon Magic sign on the regard of networking I call Directory . Directory is the button on an Energy Star * cordless phone . that is funny to me . maybe you should read it again . 🕉

  • zita666479

    I have always said a leader leads by example, a boss tells you what to do. Between the government and the activists, I have only hear words of what to do and what is wrong.
    I have been tired of waiting, now I do what is best. If it works i let as many people know as possible.
    There’s no point of being an activist is all you are going to do is talk, that is not the solution to a problem.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: