Telling people to be grateful

While I’m largely in favour of practicing gratitude, I’m also interested in the ways it doesn’t always work. Telling people to be grateful can be one of those problem points. I see this as distinctly different from encouraging people to practice gratitude, which is fine. Broad encouragement pokes people towards looking at the good things in their life, appreciating them, voicing that appreciation and so forth. Telling people to be grateful has a very different swing to it. It’s come up recently with newspapers telling black people that they ought to be more grateful over their personal achievements.

If you’re telling someone to be grateful, it assumes you know what’s going on in their lives. They may not see their situation as being one where gratitude is an appropriate response. If you’ve worked your arse off to get somewhere against great odds, being grateful for the crumbs others have dropped is not a healthy response. If we make something positive out of disaster or tragedy, we should not be pressured to feel grateful for the awfulness that set things in motion.

If one party is telling another party what to do, it tends to indicate a massive power imbalance. Telling someone how they are supposed to feel is a way of invalidating their emotional responses. It can be a way of writing off a person’s experience, background, struggles and personal effort. Focusing on the need for gratitude can draw attention away from both the work a person has done, and the barriers they faced to getting to where they are. If people are achieving things in spite of prejudice, disadvantage, illness, poverty, lack of privilege… telling them to focus on what they should be grateful for is a way of taking power away from them. It says ‘don’t look at what you did, think of everything that helped’. And that isn’t always appropriate, or fair. Using the idea of gratitude to stop people celebrating their own achievements really isn’t cool.

Telling people they should express gratitude runs the risk of turning gratitude into an act of public performance. It can stop people from being authentic. It can stop people talking about the difficulties they’ve faced. For gratitude to be meaningful, it has to be felt. If instead, it is something we feel obliged to perform to avoid criticism, it becomes a very hollow, potentially toxic activity.

It’s always worth asking why it is we want a person to express more gratitude. What do we want them to shut up about? What do we not want to think about or deal with? What of theirs are we trying to own for ourselves?

About Nimue Brown

Druid, author, dreamer, folk enthusiast, parent, wife to the most amazing artist -Tom Brown. Drinker of coffee, maker of puddings. Exploring life as a Pagan, seeking good and meaningful ways to be, struggling with mental health issues and worried about many things. View all posts by Nimue Brown

7 responses to “Telling people to be grateful

  • druidcat

    I hate being told that I should be grateful. Throughout my childhood, it was a constant background noise – which made receiving every gift like stepping on eggshells. I was Ungrateful. Constantly. No win.

    Or… I could respond honestly? Surely that’s worth more?

  • caelesti

    Yes, exactly. I’ve noticed a lot of the people who make a big deal out of such things are in very unexamined privileged settings, the same people who often idealize forgiveness without thinking about how that might affect victims/survivors of abuse/violent crime etc. The sort of people who post about their fancy vacation & hashtag it with “blessed”. No, you’re not blessed, just over-privileged! The universe/god/gods/etc. didn’t decide you’d get to go to Tahiti. I put way more stock in folks that discuss gratitude from more humble backgrounds. They have a better understanding.

  • jwdevries

    Well said!

  • Jonathan Scott Griffin

    I love your piece about how telling people to be grateful can backfire, because it sums up my feelings when people say “Happiness is a choice.” I feel that we are meant to experience a myriad of different emotions, both positive and negative. When someone says “choose to be happy,” they might as well be asking someone to lie to themselves. This I find very unhealthy because it doesn’t address emotional problems the person may be facing. It’s dishonest with oneself and how human nature works.

    • Nimue Brown

      Absolutely! What kind of monster doesn’t grieve over loss, or feel frustrated when they aren’t at their best? All emotions are valid, the only questions to ask are round how we choose to express them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: