Am I splaining?

We all do it, and often for perfectly innocent reasons. We tell people stuff they already know in a way they could find patronising and offensive. The most common innocent reason is just having learned something and being really excited about it. Given half a chance, kids and teens splain at adults. It’s good to affirm them by hearing them out and then gently letting them know that you knew. One day, they will tell you something you didn’t know and that will be exciting all round.

Sometimes we splain because we’re trying to do empathy or express that we know what it’s like, and we pitch it wrong. Sometimes in this case the splaining is in the ears of the listener, because we’re not splaining, we’re trying to tell them our truth about similar experiences. Maybe, because we’ve not previously found someone who might get what we’ve been through, we get over excited and don’t pick up on cues.

We may be someone who, due to hardware issues, can’t easily read the kind of social cues people give off when they are hearing something they know about.

This is why I won’t leap to the conclusion that I’m being splained to at the first round. I won’t default to the assumption that the other person is trying to patronise me and under-estimates my knowledge, experience and brain capacity. I wait and see what happens if I then get to say ‘yes, I know how this is.’ At that point, I might get a solidarity conversation. I might get a bit of back-pedalling, an apology or a change of direction – all of this tells me there was only the desire to share information, not to put me down. The person who ignores this and keeps splaining – then they could well be splaining for real, and I’m likely to be rude. But they could have learning difficulties or problems with social situations and I don’t want to give someone a hard time for things they have little control over.

Some of it, is about knowing how to have a conversation, and not everyone does. Rushing in with a big information dump can be a sign of social difficulty – nerves, inexperience, difficult dealing with people and the such. The more socially skilled person will ask a question to try and get a feel for what the other person knows, and will proceed slowly, so as not to look like an arse.

Splaining is definitely a thing, I’ve been on the wrong end of it. It is a thing men all too often do to women. It can be a thing adults do to younger humans. It can be a thing those who are ok do to those who are not ok – and mostly it’s about shutting the other person up, and making them feel so small and stupid that they go away. It’s about power, and it is a way of asserting social dominance.

However, like many expressions of a problem, it can be taken up and used against people who are vulnerable. It’s not a good idea to get angry with an excited child who has just splained something to you. If we’re to quick to hear splaining, we can miss that this is someone trying to express solidarity and shared experience. If they didn’t look disabled, or gay, or mixed race, and we assume we know what they are by looking…  it can be unpleasant.

Calling something ‘splaining’ can be a way to shut down a conversation, derail it and humiliate the other party. If that’s the main aim, then it needs looking at. We won’t solve the real issues of condescending explanations and misplaced assumptions by letting everything that annoys us get labelled that way.

Advertisements

About Nimue Brown

Druid, author, dreamer, folk enthusiast, parent, wife to the most amazing artist -Tom Brown. Drinker of coffee, maker of puddings. Exploring life as a Pagan, seeking good and meaningful ways to be, struggling with mental health issues and worried about many things. View all posts by Nimue Brown

9 responses to “Am I splaining?

  • Andrew Merton

    Oh god! Thinking about some of my long winded comments here and how ‘splainy’ they seem.. sorry if they seemed so to you!

  • contemplativeinquiry

    Reblogged this on contemplativeinquiry and commented:
    ‘Splaining’ – a word I hadn’t even heard until recently. The post helpfully explores this kind of communication from a number of angles.

  • Moon Pryderi

    i would have reblogged this had i been able to edit out the gender related generalisation

    ”It is a thing men all too often do to women” – and vice versa I assure you 🙂

    • Nimue Brown

      Fair point, although for context, my first encounter was with ‘mansplaining’ as a term. I’ve since run into ablesplaining and pagansplaining and no doubt there are others. You are the first person I’ve run into talking about a gender reversal there. Inevitably, anything about gender will also crop up the other way round, but the more usual takes on splaining are around cultural norms of who talks down to whom …. I’m not really making a very clear point here, I realise!

  • caelesti

    Splaining refers to a member of a group with more power condescendingly explaining someone to a member of a group with less power. Here you’re generalizing it to “overexplaining” regardless of the status of the parties involved.

    • Nimue Brown

      Yep, and it could have done with being a far longer blog post to cover more of the original context for the word. I just wanted to look at it in terms of how it can be used inappropriately as a take down and the reasons something may look like ‘splaining’ but may need a bit more thought.

  • caelesti

    Sometimes what I do is auto-explain something when it turns out to be unnecessary because I’m used to being surrounded by people with super-basic knowledge about something. Or I’m processing things aloud.

  • Sparkless

    Are you splaining for the splainers? I think sometimes people overuse a word because they don’t really understand the original meaning and then the original meaning is lost or expanded. Either way I like how you don’t just jump to a negative when someone talks to you and that is a good reminder for everyone.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: