Small space communal living

In my current family, we’ve mostly lived in small spaces. If one person plays music, everyone is listening. If one person needs a whole floor to deal with a project, everyone else has to work around that. During the years on the narrowboat, and now in a small flat, we are, when inside, in close proximity to each other.

One consequence is that we are perfectly in the habit of checking, being mindful of each other’s needs and flexing around each other. We discuss what to listen to, and what to watch. If I’m doing something sensitive – like recording audio for I know I’ll get total co-operation. When there is homework to do, no one else is watching a film. Arguments just don’t happen, most of the time none of us is irritated by anyone else.

The second consequence is that this way of living gives us involvement in each other’s life. We all know roughly what everyone else is working on and how that’s going. We know what music we can agree on, and who is reading what.

In a larger house (and I’ve done that too) the same issues are resolved by spreading out. The result is that no one really knows or has any involvement in anything anyone else is doing. People in separate rooms can often hear each other, though. I did a period of shared living where people were sleeping at different times, and although I was quiet… they were not and it really impacted on my sleeping. In a big enough house, of course you can get by with barely any impact on each other at all. As our houses get ever larger, and our families ever smaller, as we trend towards one person per house in an increasing number of properties, the co-operative good manners fostered by communal living may be less prevalent.

Our ancestors lived in much greater proximity to each other. In a poorer household all the children might well be arranged at either end of one big bed. Parents would sleep alongside the smallest children. Extended families lived together because living with your family was about the only insulation anyone had for old age. You may think the rich man in his castle had a better shot at a room to himself, but it isn’t so. You could expect a servant or two to be sleeping on the floor, even if you weren’t sharing space with your peers. The reason for four poster beds, is that those curtains are the only way a person could have any privacy!

If you can afford it, living in a big space is easy. You don’t have to pay much attention to the needs or feelings of anyone else rattling round in the big space. If no one else is near you, then you can be as self involved and inconsiderate as you like, and it doesn’t matter, and you aren’t affected by anyone else’s selfish and careless actions. When everyone has an en suit bathroom, your less than perfectly acceptable bathroom habits are never an issue.

We may feel a good deal materially richer for all having an en suit, and copious space in which to exist privately. Of course it means that we use up more resources building, furnishing, lighting and heating the space. We are poorer for not learning the co-operative skills that are integral to living closely with others. We’re also more isolated. Four people in four different rooms under the same roof can all be really lonely. We’re supposed to be a communal species, and it is worth learning to be less self-centred, and more considerate so as to reap the benefits of being able to live communally. Yes, living closely with others is more hassle, takes more effort, but we’re culturally so obsessed with ease that we forget that many of the best things life can offer require a bit of trying.


About Nimue Brown

Druid, author, dreamer, folk enthusiast, parent, wife to the most amazing artist -Tom Brown. Drinker of coffee, maker of puddings. Exploring life as a Pagan, seeking good and meaningful ways to be, struggling with mental health issues and worried about many things. View all posts by Nimue Brown

5 responses to “Small space communal living

  • the flailing Dutchwoman

    I agree with you… I like the involvement with each other’s lives that comes with living in a smaller space. When my children were babies and toddlers we lived in a tiny apartment and I always felt it was our little burrow. I did not have a baby monitor, they were always near, as they should be at that time of their lives. Now we live in an ordinary terraced house, which is quite small compared to houses elsewhere but feels big after the apartment. We have tried to keep that feel by not having televisions in the bedrooms, and gathering in the living room in the evening. Living close together is what makes a family a family.

  • Metalgaia

    An interesting point, however your family sounds really considerate. The typical American these days each having their own computer, their own tv and their own car seems very opulent compared to my childhood, and we were middle class. My family of 5 had one tv, one computer and one car. Except they could be dicks about it and didn’t really share. It was basically a wrestling match over who would get control of the tv and computer. This also involved my mom walking in front of the tv and basically interrupting most of our tv shows, or my dad changing the channel to the news right when I was in the middle of a cartoon. Or if I was trying to do my homework, I couldn’t concentrate because my younger sister was running around, throwing things and screaming her head off. Also, when my older sister and I slept in the same room, she hogged most of the room to herself.

    So living in small places can be good with considerate people, but if your family members are dicks, it kind of sucks. Now that I’m an adult I finally have privacy and I’m looooving it!

    But your right, it does make people more insular in general.

    • Nimue Brown

      It does depend on a collective decision to work co-cooperatively, but the smaller the space, the more critical a skill it becomes. Two years on a tiny narrowboat, it was either co-operate or go mad. Easier for kids if adults are modeling co-operative behaviour and encouraging, rewarding and enabling it. Much harder to do if you don’t know what it looks like!

      • Metalgaia

        That’s true! I think the problem is that my parents weren’t laying the groundwork for this kind of environment, because they fought with each other a lot. So everything definitely depends on the parents and the kind of attitude they spread to their children.

      • Nimue Brown

        hard breaking those ancestral habits and patterns for what seems normal – but not impossible!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: