Sons and Daughters of Robin Hood

Robin Hood is one of archetypal British English myth figures. Outlawed by an unjust system, he and his men hung out in Sherwood Forest practicing wealth redistribution, by stealing from the rich to give to the poor. Let’s not get bogged down in any actual historical complexities here, of which there are many, or any of that ‘men in tights’ malarkey, either. Robin Hood is an icon of taking the law into your own hands to fight injustice.

Part of the point with Robin Hood, is that you only need to invoke him when the system is broken. When tyrants rule, when everything is bent to serve the few at the expense of the many, then you need to invoke Robin Hood. There comes a time when working with the system becomes impossible, and leaping out of the undergrowth in the kit of your choice for a bit of direct action is the only option left. Well, that or lie down in the mud and wait to be trampled over.

So here we are, warming up to cull badgers in spite of the total absence of scientific evidence to back it up as a solution to bovine TB. We’re getting ready to frack, despite all the science that suggests it could be dangerous, and assures us that a lot of harmful chemicals will be going into the atmosphere and a lot of water will be required. The economists who gave us the theory that austerity is the only answer to our problems, came back and acknowledged the maths was wrong. All around the world, economists are pointing out that austerity doesn’t actually do the job it is supposed to do. Our government puts its hands over its ears and carries on. We’re sending terminally ill people back to work because… no actually, I don’t even know what the justification is for this, and we’ve instituted a bedroom tax that further cripples the poor while manifestly costing the public purse even more money.


I have no problem with politics that are about differences of opinion and reasonable differences of interpretation. There are places where science isn’t clear (one glass of red wine a day? Or not?) There are times when preference, taste and ideals have a very important role to play in politics. But for all the stuff that is about the numbers, the bottom line, scientific realities and other such non-squishy, not-soft data, there is only one way to go in a reasonable society, and that is to be led by the evidence.

The evidence all goes one way, the government goes another.
I would like to live in a society where tolerance and reason predominate. I would like to live in a country that pays attention to evidence, basis policy on available information, and where politicians have the guts to deal with it when the best advise available, changes. Not a world in which we pay scientists to tell us what we wanted to hear. I also quite fancy living in a democracy. I’ve heard about them, and the idea looks really good on paper. You vote for people, and then you can communicate with them to express your views, and they represent you and a bunch of other people. Sounds really good. So, if, to pluck an example out of the air, a country was up in arms demanding that its wildlife not be slaughtered based on an irrational ignoring of all the science… in a democracy, that would be taken seriously. We should try that thing some time.

In the meantime, fighting trousers, or green tights, or whatever else it is you put on when there’s nothing sensible left to do. Here’s a link to Damh the Bard’s awesome anthem to non-cooperation, have a listen, and do not undertake to lie down in the mud to be trampled over just yet…

Then go and read the party political broadcast on behalf of the Bard party…

It is, increasingly, a revolting situation.

About Nimue Brown

Druid, author, dreamer, folk enthusiast, parent, polyamourous animist, ant-fash, anti-capitalist, bisexual steampunk. Drinker of coffee, maker of puddings. Exploring life as a Pagan, seeking good and meaningful ways to be, struggling with mental health issues and worried about many things. View all posts by Nimue Brown

12 responses to “Sons and Daughters of Robin Hood

  • Rachel

    I’m with you 100%. I’ve signed every petition going against the badger cull and fracking and it makes me sick that despite all the evidence, public outcry etc this Government carries on regardless.

    One can only hope that they don’t do the same with regard to Syria.

  • Morrighan's Trove

    I agree with you completely, but trust me when I say, it isn’t much better in a democracy.

    The people that we vote in, has this nasty habit of doing the opposite of what they promised or nothing at all! I love my country, but sometimes I have to wonder what goes on between the campaign and holding the office that makes politicians do this!

    Don’t get me started on their inabilities to not argue like children, or we’d be here all day!

    In closing, I believe in Democracy. Just not in the way it is run. Because, like the Sheriff of Nottingham, these politicians have a lot of power and use it to keep the little man down. We just need to learn compassion and to love everyone as our equal.

  • Robert

    Though I am aligned with the thoughts—–How easy it is to assume we are right. A science fact is good only until the next momoment and data point—–Democracy can become tyranny ——Representatives follow their myopic views and power currupts the average human soul—-Be careful what we wish for—-Scientist-Taoist and Druid

  • Jeff Lilly (@druidjournal)

    As someone once said, capitalism defeated communism in the 1990’s, and it’s well on its way to defeating democracy as well.

  • Robert

    Both conservative crapitalism and liberal facism are dangerous—I speak as a contemporary taoist seeing the knives hidden between the pinnion of your angelic wings—-ah! How sanctomony can rule the mind.

    • Nimue Brown

      All absolute positions are dangerous, or hold the potential to be so, even the best intentioned ones. I try to hold a dash of ‘perhaps’ and ‘maybe’ in all my thinking to avoid this. So long as we remember that we could be wrong, and are open to being persuaded, we are probably safe enough.

  • corvusrouge

    On a very pedantic point and as someone born and brought up a bicycle ride away from Sherwood forest, it is considered by local historians that the Robin Hood stories are actualy based on Jack in the Green. :-p

    • Nimue Brown

      Heh, hence the bit at the start about not getting into those, I gather the ‘good old King Richard’ stories don’t stand much scrutiny… I had encountered the Robin/Jack idea before, there’s something rather resonant about it.

  • R is for… Relationship and Reciprocity | Léithin Cluan

    […] Our collective relationship with the land isn’t great, at the moment. The UK badger cull started recently, in pilot areas around the country. It is unscientific, essentially political, and […]

  • Always Activism

    applause applause … excellent post!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: